In 1939, folks in Florida couldn’t agree on which Thursday was Thanksgiving. President Franklin D. Roosevelt had his pick, and Gov. Fred P. Cone had his. That put everybody else in a bit of a pickle. Who do you listen to? When do you put the turkey in? Florida’s bankers took both Thursdays off. If anybody felt the Thanksgiving bloat that year, it was probably them. Here’s the story.
J. Carlisle Rogers had a plan if the Thanksgiving turkey didn’t stretch to the following Thursday. He’d already cleaned his gun, he wrote, and figured he could make do with doves or quail. This was in a Nov. 10, 1939, bulletin to the Florida Bankers Association. Rogers, a cashier at the First National Bank of Leesburg and the association’s secretary-treasurer, had just finished explaining why Florida banks should take two Thursdays off. It seemed only natural to give some thought to what he’d eat on the second one, according to a document in the Florida State Archives.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt had picked Nov. 23 for Thanksgiving, but Gov. Fred P. Cone had declared it Nov. 30. That put folks in a bit of a pickle. When did you put the turkey in? It depended on whose calendar you were going by.
The last Thursday of the month had been the custom for decades, but in 1939 November had five Thursdays. With Thanksgiving falling on the 30th, merchants worried there wouldn’t be enough time for Christmas shopping. The country was still in midst of the Great Depression, and Roosevelt figured moving the holiday up a week might help stores sell a little more, according to an article in the National Archives titled, "Thanksgiving: Another FDR Experiment."

In Tampa, Maas Brothers president J.A. Waterman had already written to Cone in September to make the case for an earlier holiday. He knew the colleges preferred the later date because they had football games lined up. Waterman had an answer for that, too. Play the games at night, he suggested. He figured they might even draw a bigger crowd. Cone could not be persuaded and kept the 30th.

Sarasota’s merchants went ahead and made up their own minds. On Oct. 26, P.M. Birmingham, secretary of the Sarasota Retail Merchants Association, sent Cone a short letter about a decision made at the association’s Monday night meeting. They’d go with Nov. 23, the date Roosevelt had chosen. Birmingham got the whole thing into one sentence, signed his name and sent it off to Tallahassee. If only the banks had been able to settle it that neatly.
Cone had already asked Florida Attorney General George Couper Gibbs what the banks were supposed to do. The state law recognized a day set aside by the president or the governor. Gibbs took the singular seriously and concluded that only one of the two dates could be the legal holiday. He went with the president’s. State Comptroller J.M. Lee read things differently. As Rogers reported in his bulletin, Lee considered both dates legal holidays and wanted banks across Florida to follow the same schedule. The bankers’ association met in Miami and come up with a practical solution of its own. Once the president made the 23rd official, the association recommended observing both Thursdays. If anybody felt the Thanksgiving bloat that year, my money’s on the bankers.

The extra Thursday off was a luxury Florida teachers could have used. In New York, the national convention for English teachers was scheduled for that state’s Thanksgiving break. On Nov. 17, Alice Colvin Wright, president of the New York City Association of English Teachers, wrote to Cone asking him to encourage Florida school boards to grant leave on Nov. 23 and 24. By then the teachers who wanted to go had less than a week to sort it out, according to the Florida Memory Project.

Roosevelt went ahead and carved his turkey on the 23rd in Warm Springs, Georgia. There’s a photograph of him with a carving knife in hand, Eleanor Roosevelt on one side and a little girl on the other, the bird taking up a good stretch of the table.
For some families around the country, Thanksgiving dinner was still a week away. The split persisted through 1941. By then Congress had settled on the fourth Thursday of November, and Roosevelt signed the resolution the day after Christmas. In years with five Thursdays, as in 1939, the fourth would come with a week of November still on the calendar.
Rogers went straight from Thanksgiving dinner to asking his fellow bankers for tips on bank robbers. I wish he’d given us one more line about the turkey. Did it last till the 30th, or did a perfectly innocent quail have to pay for Florida’s second Thanksgiving?
Comments
No comments on this item
Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.