Manatee County commissioners voted unanimously on Thursday to delay adopting proposed updates to the 2050 road map series in the county’s Comprehensive Plan.
Residents who submitted written public comments ahead of the meeting—as well as those who spoke in person at Thursday’s hearing—raised concerns about two proposed road extensions depicted on the maps. They argued that extending 44th Avenue East and Rangeland Parkway east of the county’s Future Development Area Boundary (FDAB) would pave the way for urban sprawl and heavier traffic in the county’s rural areas.
Following the staff presentation, Commissioner George Kruse addressed residents' concerns directly, noting that the controversial road segments were not new additions to the maps. Staff confirmed that the dotted lines have been part of the county’s Comprehensive Plan since 2014, long before any of the current commissioners took office, Kruse pointed out.
Kruse said that after reading residents' emails, he asked county staff about removing the segments, but staff said state officials had advised the county that Senate Bill 180 legally prohibits it from taking them off the map.
“I’m not building any new roads ever. We don’t have the money to maintain them,” Kruse said. “But while Senate Bill 180 is here, they specifically told us we were prohibited from removing roads from this map.”
Kruse acknowledged that additional east-west routes could ease congestion on State Roads 64 and 70, but said the county cannot afford to build or maintain the extensions and pledged to vote against any future construction funding. He also told residents they could return in November 2027 to request removing the lines then if Senate Bill 180’s restrictions expire, or speak out if either project is ever proposed for the Capital Improvement Plan.
“I promise you if it comes up and someone says we need a budget amendment to build those roads, I will vote no on it. But I cannot promise you that I will vote not to finalize this (today), or to remove these dotted lines, because I physically cannot. I legally cannot,” Kruse said.
He added, “I get your concern. I agree with your concern. I’m on your side with your concern… but there’s nothing I can physically do today to solve your concern.”
Commissioner Bob McCann said he wanted the full board to commit to not approving future projects or funds for the extensions shown on the map.
McCann said he agreed with Kruse’s position, but questioned how much assurance one commissioner’s pledge to vote no on future funding could give residents. He recalled prior instances where he voted against projects but was overruled. McCann also noted that even if the current board were to commit to a collective ‘no’ vote on the specific roadway expansions, the current board cannot bind future commissioners to the same.
McCann said residents were justified in their concern about what the maps showed, particularly given the increased development in eastern Manatee County and the congestion on existing roadways.
“These people are here. They’re up in arms because this map says that you can build these roads,” McCann said. “I would love to hear this whole board say, you know, what we want to do is we want to work for the people and actually say and commit to you, we will not build these roads no matter what.”
McCann added that he intends to advocate that Tallahassee, under the incoming gubernatorial administration, reconsider the state’s strict interpretation of Senate Bill 180 and what constitutes a more "burdensome” restriction.
Newly elected District 1 Commissioner Liz Arnold also urged the board to set the approval aside. Arnold said her district had gone without representation for a significant portion of the past three years and needed more time to discuss the proposal. She advocated withdrawing or delaying adoption of the updated maps to see what happens with Senate Bill 180, which has also held up the county’s efforts to repeal Policy 2.1.2.8 and restore local wetland protections.
“So why don’t we just take this off the table for now?” Arnold asked.
Chair Tal Siddique also initially suggested setting the amendment aside early in the discussion, but after staff explained that the proposed maps carried forward the two disputed extensions from earlier maps, he said he was prepared to support adoption. Siddique said the update would bring required road classifications west of the FDAB in line with state transportation standards. He also said some of the changes could make it easier for commercial proposals to move through the county’s approval process.
When Assistant County Attorney Sarah Schenk explained that the amendment would be deemed withdrawn on Dec. 28 if the board took no action, and that a formal continuance would keep the proposal pending and give commissioners until spring to take it up again, McCann suggested that the extra time would reveal whether the incoming administration in Tallahassee might interpret SB 180 differently.
Once staff confirmed that work on East River Ranch Boulevard could proceed under its existing approval even if the board delayed the map update, Kruse said he saw little reason to rush adoption of the updated maps.
“I’ve changed my mind,” Kruse said. “I agree with what Commissioner McCann said.”
Commissioner Mike Rahn, who had initially voiced support for adoption, moved to delay for 180 days and re-advertise for a new hearing before May 18, 2027. McCann seconded the motion.
After the motion to delay, Siddique opened public comment.
More than a dozen citizens addressed the board. Some asked commissioners to commit to not extending 44th Avenue East beyond Bourneside Boulevard, while others raised concerns about congestion, roadway safety, and flooding. Among those who stepped to the podium was Phillip Upton, a Manatee County resident of more than 50 years.
Phillip Upton told commissioners he had lived on 257th Street for 36 years and that he and his wife had raised their children there. He asked the board to leave 44th Avenue East as it is.
“With the roads come more people,” Upton said. “We don’t want more people. We’re happy the way we are.”
Matt Woods urged commissioners to wait until the county could better explain why the extensions were needed, how they might affect development and what they would cost. Another speaker urged the board to address congestion on existing roads west of the FDAB before considering expanding roads east.
After public comment closed, Siddique joined the rest of the board in voting to continue the hearing. The delay passed unanimously.
Ordinance 26-01 would update the standards the county uses to evaluate peak-hour traffic on major roads and revise maps showing future lane counts and right-of-way. The amendment would also classify existing and future roads by the type of development around them and incorporate the county’s Trail Master Plan into the map series.
View the proposed 2050 road map series below: Map 5-B, on page 2, shows the future extensions of 44th Avenue East and Rangeland Parkway.
(Note: the agenda packet maps above are labeled “BOCC Adopted 11/19/2026," but commissioners ultimately voted to continue the adoption hearing).
Before returning for its final adoption Thursday, the proposal went through two local hearings and state review. The Planning Commission voted 4-2 in February to recommend transmitting it to the state, and county commissioners followed with a 4-2 vote in June, with Commissioners Bob McCann and Jason Bearden opposing transmittal.
For now, the existing Comprehensive Plan maps—including the dotted lines for both controversial roadway extensions—remain in effect while the board decides on a new adoption hearing date ahead of the May 18, 2027, deadline.
To watch the staff presentation, board discussion, public comments, and vote on PA-25-13 / Ordinance 26-01 from the Nov. 19, 2026, Manatee County Commission land use meeting, click the video below.
1 comment on this item
Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.
EcoActivist
Manatee residents - stay engaged and informed! This is not over!
9 hours ago Report this