Log in Subscribe
local government

Manatee County Commission Notes: 12/17/26

Posted

The League of Women Voters of Manatee County Government Committee observes Manatee County Commission meetings for items of interest to citizens and the League, and notes adherence to, or nonadherence to, good governance procedures and the Sunshine Law. The following are the major points from the board’s regular meeting on 12/17/26.

Link to the Agenda and Video

ANNOUNCEMENTS

Updates to Agenda - November 13, November 17, 2026

AWARDS/PRESENTATIONS/PROCLAMATIONS

Awards

Presentation of 2026 November Team Member of the Month

Team Member of the Month Award was presented to Nate Masengale, Landfill Operator at the Lena Road landfill. He was recognized for his willingness to always jump in to get the job done – including additional work during heavy workload times like hurricane clean up efforts. He also stepped up to become a valued member of the county’s community outreach program. His colleagues say everything runs smoothly when he shows up.

Presentations

Aviata Roof Collapse Agency Recognition

On July 25, 2026, a partial roof collapse at Aviata at Bradenton Villas required the

evacuation of 157 assisted-living residents. The BOCC presentation was to recognize the rapid, well-coordinated response by multiple agencies to move medically fragile residents without any injuries. The response involved Bradenton Fire Department, Bradenton Police Department, Manatee County EMS, Emergency Management, Emergency Communications (9-1-1), facility personnel, and mutual-aid agencies across Tampa Bay. Over a 12-hour period, responders moved residents from the facility, provided medical and mobility assistance as needed, coordinated transportation, maintained resident accountability, and supported relocation to receiving facilities.

Proclamations

Farm City Week

Commissioner Liz Arnold presented the proclamation to the Manatee County Farm City Week Committee. For 71 years, the Committee has worked to connect Manatee County’s agricultural community with the broader public. Agriculture provides $322 million annually to the county economy. Activities during Farm City Week and throughout the year increase awareness and appreciation of local agriculture and help residents understand the relationship between farms, consumers, businesses, schools, and the local economy.

Model Manatee County Government Civics Education Program Day

The Model Manatee County Government Civics Education Program had its inaugural class on September 14, 2026. This class is filled with future leaders who are currently in their junior or senior year of high school and want to learn more about their local government. One of the students created a Manatee County Civics Game covering what was learned in the class and he hopes to bring it to the county schools for middle and high school students. 

REQUESTS BY COMMISSIONERS (Items to be pulled from Consent Agenda)

Item #25 was pulled by Commissioner George Kruse and Item #33 by Commissioner Bob McCann.

CONSENT AGENDA

The League encourages residents to read the full meeting agenda to learn about the approved consent items.

Approved 7-0

ADVISORY BOARD COMMENTS AND UPDATES

Tourist Development Council

Approval of $35,000 in One-Time Funding for the Florida vs. Florida State Legacy Weekend Tailgate and Watch Party, Bradenton Area Convention and Visitors Bureau - Countywide 

Commissioners questioned the utility of this in light of Amendment 3 but approved given it is a one-time event funded with tourist tax dollars.

Approved 6-1. Poulton opposed. 

CITIZEN COMMENTS (Consideration for Future Agenda Items - 30 Minute Time Limit)

A citizen complained that the new web-based system for submitting written public comments can jumble text and render some comments unreadable by the public. 

Rusty Chinnis, a prominent Florida Gulf Coast clean-water advocate and conservationist, pointed out the Manatee County Bond Referendum passed overwhelmingly on November 3rd.

Two residents of Oakwood Estates development complained that they had requested a sign identifying their community, correction of drainage issues, and installation of speed bumps for many years but had received no support or response from the county. 

Commissioner Amanda Ballard and Chair Tal Siddique offered their assistance and directed them to staff who would assist them.

ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA

Item 25. Execution of Change Order No. 1 to Agreement No. 24-R084481SAM for Professional Architectural Design Services for Manatee County Warrior Memorial and Veteran Connections Hub, Aaron Rawley, Project Manager – District 1 

Change order was for an additional $406,307 in design services on top of previously approved $251,868. Kruse’s concern was the constraints of Amendment 3 may mean the buildings and statues in Valor Commons, a 24-acre veterans' memorial and resource campus in Palmetto, may not be built.

Failed 7-0.

Item 33. Authorization to hire seven fully grant-funded FTEs to support the Lasting Manatee Program, Ashley Schnitker, Grants Division Manager 

McCann asked for clarification and confirmation that the seven FTEs were fully grant-funded.

Approved 7-0.

ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS - LEGISLATIVE

Item 66. Adoption of Resolution R-26-149 regarding changes to the Infrastructure Sales Tax Project and Equipment List to add two (2) projects in the Transportation category. One (1) in the Major Road Improvements subcategory and one (1) in the Intersection Improvements subcategory; and Adoption of Budget Resolutions B-27-024 and B-27-028, Claudia Campos, Chief Financial Officer

Commissioners felt these additional turn lanes and traffic lights would improve public safety and therefore are important to fund.

Approved 6-1. McCann opposed.

REGULAR

Development Services

Item 67. Approval of Revised 2026 Board of County Commissioners Meeting Calendar, Nicole Knapp, Development Services Director - Countywide

The following changes were made to the schedule:

  • The December 1 Regular BOCC meeting is cancelled.
  • The BoCC Regular meeting on January 5 was changed to January 12, January 7 was changed to January 14, and a Land Use meeting was added on January 21.

Approved 7-0.

Financial Management

Item 68. Audit Discussion: Early Market Outreach and Board Direction on Audit Scope and Cooperative Procurement, Brent Sargent, Purchasing Official

Only one bid response was received from an external vendor to perform an independent outside forensic audit of Manatee County government contracts, capital improvement projects, and discretionary spending, and no cost estimate was included because the scope was unclear. 

Citizen Comments

Three citizens commented that the county should not proceed unless there were three valid bids.

Commissioners moved to have the time frame scope set as 2021 through 2026, and have the Clerk perform the initial audit.

Approved 7-0.

Public Safety

Item 69. Update on proposed updates to Ordinance 25-35, requirements for the operation of Bicycles (including e-bikes and e-scooters), Jodie Fiske, Public Safety Director

Public Safety Director Fiske provided some statistics on the increase in high acuity incidents involving electrified/motorized bikes/scooters/emotos. Most of the incidents involved children ages 9-14. McCann asked if there had been any fatalities – the answer was none in Manatee County. Fiske also detailed the complications and inability to enforce age restrictions on children and speed limits on devices that don’t have speedometers. Her recommendation was to stop efforts to update Ordinance 25-35. County Attorney Pamela D’Agostino said her staff had spent more than 30 hours on the possible update and wanted guidance on whether they should continue doing so. Fiske further recommended an aggressive education outreach approach using free resources such as the John Hopkins e-bike safety program and the county schools. 

Citizen Comments

  • A citizen commented that pedestrians are endangered by e-bikes.
  • A citizen stated that most parents don’t have the skills to teach their children e-bike safety because they have no e-bike experience themselves.
  • A trauma nurse stated that kids are not mature enough to safely control e-bikes. She further pointed out that Manatee County does not have a pediatric trauma center. That means a serious pediatric trauma has to be air-lifted out of the county, and any subsequent fatality would not be reported in Manatee County.

Commissioners moved to have Public Safety focus on aggressive education outreach and told D’Agostino to cease efforts to write an ordinance update.

Approved 7-0.

Public Works

Item 70. Execution of a Reimbursement and Impact Fee Credit Agreement with Benderson Development Company, LLC, for Transportation Improvements, Scott May, P.E., County Engineer – District 2 

Because the project by Benderson Development will impact transportation, they must pay transportation impact fees which will be netted against transportation improvements the developer is making.

Approved 6-1. McCann opposed.

REPORTS

Administrator

Item 71. Discussion on Planning for Potential Impacts of Amendment 3 in Manatee County, Charlie Bishop, County Administrator

County Administrator Bishop explained that the county will face significant financial challenges with an estimated budget cut of $62.9 million in year one, and $113 million in year two. The county also needs $33 million to restore reserves to respond to hurricanes and other emergencies. The county has 5 principles throughout this process: 1) protecting essential services; 2) reducing spending first; 3) evaluating services, not just departments; 4) protecting financial stability; and 5) engaging the community. He cautioned that significant budget reductions could affect service levels and staffing, noting 118 positions have already been frozen. 

Siddique argued that given the 65% of voters who clearly voted to pay less taxes, the county should respond by prioritizing spending cuts rather than introducing new fees or fines. He proposed planning for implementing Year Two budget cuts immediately (approximately $113 million), replenishing reserves, reducing debt, and clarifying actual service impacts. He also called for greater budget transparency and a clearer distinction between base and continuation spending to know the cost of “keeping the lights on.” He recommended maintaining current-year budgets for law enforcement and first responders, with no layoffs of deputies or first responders. He also suggested considering restructuring departments and discontinuing certain services.

Kruse argued that the Board should begin addressing budget reductions immediately rather than wait until the January work session. He questioned whether the projected savings of $63 million and $113 million were sufficient, citing state estimates of $80 million and $149 million. He urged the County to plan for deeper first-year cuts to avoid a future budget shortfall. He opposed tax increases or tax shifts, emphasizing that voters supported reducing services to achieve savings. Kruse also challenged the idea that the Sheriff’s budget could be fully protected, noting that available revenue would not support it. Kruse proposed exploring the sale or long-term leasing of County assets, such as sports facilities and libraries, to transfer maintenance costs to private operators. He also called for ending TIF arrangements (building now based on future tax revenue) and interlocal agreements that use County resources to support municipalities, nonprofits, and the School Board.

McCann noted that state leadership in Tallahassee rejected the call for a meeting on Amendment 3 and counties lack guidance on where the money is supposed to come from. The Sheriff's Department just changed health insurance and the Board is not sure how much it will cost. Many non-essential things can wait such as parks and everything on the Capital Improvement Plans (CIP). McCann agreed that there should be no new taxes. He also recommended looking at bonds to see if the county will be able to make the payments, reviewing costs of vehicle maintenance and fuel, and assessing all personnel and whether the job functions are really necessary. The Board doesn’t want to cut essential services, so it should cut CIP and hold on parks and libraries. 

Siddique agreed that the Board should cut infrastructure costs while still needing safety improvements. Building new library extensions and parks should stop. He also mentioned the pending impact fees lawsuit, which may not be resolved by January 2027 and the county may not win. Siddique advised being careful about asset sales at a loss, for example keeping Central Library but selling the Seafood Shack. He recommended using the already scheduled reserve policy workshop on December 9 to start budget discussions and hearing from employees and the public.

McCann made a motion for a special meeting on December 9 to discuss the budget.

Approved 7-0.

Development Services

Item 72. Short Term Rentals (STR) Update - Nicole Knapp, Director

Due to a conflict of interest disclosed by Commissioner Elizabeth Arnold, she recused herself from voting on this matter.

Knapp introduced the new division manager for Code Compliance Jody Maybush, explaining his regulatory oversight and ex-military experience. Knapp explained that a workshop took place in September to discuss short-term rentals and that they agreed to come back to the commission today. She highlighted the history of board actions on the topic and that they are seeking board recommendations.

Stephanie Taylor, Deputy Director, Building Division and Enforcement Division, gave a detailed overview of the history of Florida legislation and concluded that the county does not currently have a short-term rental (STR) ordinance or grandfathered regulations, and state law significantly limits local authority to restrict vacation rentals but they can regulate things like trash, noise, parking, and lighting. Approximately 2,856 STRs operate in unincorporated Manatee County.

Taylor presented three options. Option 1 maintains existing regulations with no new short-term rental registration, renewal, or county-initiated inspections. It would continue enforcing existing codes, provide clarification on rental operations, process complaints consistently with other county complaints, and refer state licensing and tax issues to the appropriate agencies. Staff also suggested potentially filling vacant Code Enforcement positions. Option 2 is for comprehensive regulation with a new software-based registration and renewal program, requiring fire district inspections, offering additional Development Services inspections for life and pool safety, and enforcing existing codes through citations, violations, and potentially suspensions for repeat violations. Additional Code Enforcement staffing would be needed to administer the program. Option 3 is for simplified mandatory registration without renewals, requiring fire district inspections, and enforcing existing codes through citations and notices of violation. This option would provide a more limited regulatory approach.

A comprehensive program could require additional staffing, with estimated software costs of $50,000 to more than $150,000 annually and staffing costs of approximately $750,000. Staff also recommended a phased implementation, beginning in West Bradenton, where STR concentrations are highest.

Commissioners discussed the need for a county ordinance but limitations on what they can and cannot regulate given passage of Florida State Senate Bill 180, which freezes counties' and cities' ability to adopt more restrictive or burdensome land-development regulations and comprehensive plan amendments.

Citizen Comments

Ten citizens overwhelmingly urged stronger regulation and enforcement of STRs, citing neighborhood impacts such as noise, parties, overcrowding, parking problems, trespassing, safety concerns, property damage, and strain on public resources. Several argued that existing codes may already prohibit transient lodging but are inadequately enforced, particularly because property owners face few consequences. Common recommendations included occupancy limits, minimum-stay requirements, 24/7 local management, quiet hours, parking restrictions, and higher fees or fines to fund enforcement. One speaker, while working for owners of STRs, advocated responsible management measures including holding owners responsible, trash services, and noise-monitoring technology.

Martha Jane Flynn, from the Board of Directors for Pine Meadow Home Owners Association, said 24 of the neighborhood’s 100 homes are short-term rentals, including oversized properties accommodating 16–30-plus guests. She described escalating noise, lighting, parking, and safety concerns near an elementary school and playground, increased Sheriff calls, and significant resident stress. She also shared data on STR trends in Pine Meadow, which are similar as those in other parts of Manatee County. She urged stronger STR regulations and enforcement.

Commissioner Comments

Siddique asked to use existing county software and data systems rather than purchasing expensive new technology. He also sought clarification on prior commission direction and requested a clear implementation plan, noting following staff clarifications that a finalized, legally reviewed ordinance would not be ready by December. Knapp committed to sharing estimated operational costs of a new STR system in December and that legal review on a new ordinance would happen later.

McCann proposed an amended motion, adding using existing county resources Tax Collector data, and Peregrine software. It was clarified that Tax Collector data cannot be used due to Florida Statute 213.053 which protects tourist development tax information as confidential, preventing disclosure of registered individuals or properties. 

Following discussion, the commission amended the motion to direct staff to draft for future board consideration STR registration and annual renewal options, including anticipated operating costs, and recommend Land Development Code amendments pursuant to implementing a STR ordinance using existing public safety and county resources.

McCann made a motion to take action on Option 2 with a request to present financial options on operational costs at the December 15 meeting, prior to completion of legal review in February.

Approved 6-0. Arnold abstained.

CITIZEN COMMENTS (Continuation of Consideration for Future Agenda Items, if needed)

A West Bradenton resident in District 6, reported that a nearby three-bedroom home is renting to groups of up to 14 transient workers. She raised concerns about guest accountability when only one name is on the reservation, its proximity to a school, trucks obstructing emergency access, and neighborhood disruption. This prompted a longtime neighbor to move away.

 GOVERNANCE

Link to Good Governance Guidelines

The meeting was well-run. Although conversations were difficult, they maintained a level of collegiality.  

There was considerable discussion about whether to play a YouTube video requested to be shown by a citizen and whether there was an issue with copyright. The county staff should refine procedures on showing of external media during the meeting, requiring advance approval.

Although rescheduling of meetings makes it difficult, given the extraordinary circumstances of the passage of Amendment 3, we applaud the Commissioners’ flexibility to prioritize scheduling time to carefully review, get public feedback, and make informed changes to the budget.

Comments

No comments on this item

Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.