In July of 2024, the City of Bradenton voted to sell the riverfront property where City Hall currently sits to a New York City developer in partnership with local commercial builder NDC Construction. This week, we learned that the development group has withdrawn from the deal, citing increased building costs as a driving factor. The city says it plans to surplus the property again and look for another buyer.
The benefit of the deal going bust is that, two and a half years on, the city still hasn't identified a new property for City Hall. There were musings about the city taking over space in the nearby Manatee County Administration Building now that the county has, for reasons I still can't comprehend, moved what appears to be a majority of its operations to an east county building near the Sarasota/Manatee County line it purchased for roughly $35 million ($24 million, plus $11 million for renovations), despite it being nearly three decades old and requiring a $12.5 million backup generator service leasing agreement with FPL, or so we were told. Employees have complained about the long, arduous commute through gridlocked traffic and inadequate bathroom facilities that, I’m told, have led some to visit nearby businesses to use the restroom.
This purchase was funded with money earmarked for the badly deteriorated parking garage at the increasingly empty downtown Bradenton admin building, whose repairs we were supposed to believe were somehow no longer as critical, despite plenty of evidence to the contrary. Some suggested the garage would be rebuilt to include a sorely needed downtown grocery store, but for now, it continues to decay with no plans made public.
The county still owns the massive swath of land adjacent to its Lena Road landfill that it purchased in 2020 to create a future east county campus, but instead of beginning development, it instead chose to buy a poorly located, 28-year-old building in need of considerable maintenance and empty out much of the facility it already owned.
In September, Manatee County Commissioners voted to transfer the former GTE building in downtown Bradenton from Manatee County to the City of Bradenton. The county had previously sold it to the Florida Cultural Group, an umbrella organization that operates the Manatee Performing Arts Center, the Manatee Players community theater, and 20 other programs, for $150,000 in 2021. In 2024, the county bought it back from that organization for $483,000.
It is alleged that it might become a satellite campus for Pittsburgh-based Point Park University. If that does not happen, we are told it might go back to the Florida Cultural Group.
What was the plan? Did the city rush to sell its City Hall property to a politically connected developer, with a deal in place to inherit much of the downtown county administration building? Was that why the county moved so fast to buy the Lakewood Ranch building, with no public discussion that such an acquisition was even being considered? Did they have grand visions of a redeveloped downtown that have slowly fallen apart, and is the music about to stop without everyone having a chair now that Amendment 3 has passed?
I don’t know. What I do know is that I warned that it shouldn't surprise anyone in our local government when voters passed Amendment 3. Now those chickens have come home to roost, and commissioners are—with a straight face, mind you—warning citizens of the consequences of that vote.
November’s elections may have kept a business-as-usual majority on the board, which will continue to empower the inept administration that got us here. From what I saw in the Observer, commissioners and top bureaucrats alike celebrated that fact on Election Night. Time will tell, however, whether they’ve won anything more than to rule over an empire of ashes.
Dennis "Mitch" Maley is an editor and columnist for The Bradenton Times and the host of our weekly podcast. With over two decades of experience as a journalist, he has covered Manatee County government since 2010. He is a graduate of Shippensburg University and later served as a Captain in the U.S. Army. Click here for his bio. Mitch's new novel, Fish Kill, is currently available here, along with his previous books. He can be reached at editor@thebradentontimes.com.
1 comment on this item
Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.
JeffHale34205
It really is amazing the issue of Bradenton City Hall is still unresolved. As residents may recall, as far back as 2014 the city declined to agree to a long-term lease of the city auditorium (to a company who was drawing 7000-8000 people a month downtown to a display of working models of Leonardo da Vinci inventions during its short-term lease) because city managers wanted to sell the building. By 2016 the city said the auditorium had reached the point of costing more money to operate than to keep it closed. The costs of this under-utilized building have been a big factor in arguments for the sale of the property.
7 hours ago Report this