Good article and I plan on voting against the bill even though I am a home owners. However, while I realize this is a far left paper (at east opinion part), I wish there would be some (maybe one) articles/op-eds arguing the other side. It helps make for an informed voter.
Add these issues to the long list of documented examples of a complete lack of integrity shown by Charlie Bishop. Yet this and previous boards seem afraid to fulfill their oversight responsibilities. Not only has Mr Bishop not been held accountable - commissioners haven’t even asked questions. They know he violated public records law - they put a clause in his new contract requiring him to comply. They know he is responsible for falsely claiming that removing wetland buffers was “county initiated.” And that he used taxpayer money to hire Beruff’s consultant to pitch the lie. We are still paying for that fraud in legal fees and the loss of wetlands. A new board should demand an investigation into how that went down. Into how our own staff was ordered silent. Another recent example is the disastrous decision to purchase cheaply made kennel trailers for our shelter. Then Mr Bishop vindictively pursued volunteers for exposing their unsuitability. Vindictiveness is Mr Bishop’s management style. We have not had a county leader with integrity since Beruff and Pedicini, through their puppet commissioners, pushed out Cheri Coryea. First we got Hopes, then KVO slipped in Charlie Bishop in the same meeting in which he (KVO) rejected the national search candidates - after we paid to fly them in. An organization is a reflection of its leader. It is long past time Manatee had an administrator who leads by example.
Commissioners totally do not understand the issues created by Airbnb and short term rentals. They refuse to workshop or discuss, their only concern is the 30+ million in bed tax collected....meanwhile they leave residents in a very dangerous situation as they are forced to manage the disaster created by these disrespectful guests. This is a serious safety issue for residents. These owners should be responsible for their guests but they are not. Something needs to change. All complaints should be attached to the agenda so they can no longer be hidden. Thank you LWV for your notes and citizen comment information.
Than you Bob for clear intelligent thougtful commentary. You say here what we all see every day. You are in the trenches each day and see the real world happenings and real time destruction of the quality of life in our once beautiful and now UGLY county thanks to the unbridled uncontrolled greed of the BERUFFS NEALS BENDERSONS REX JENSON SMR and national builders and the complete destruction of our quality of life. It will be very difficult to fight the stooge lackeys on the county commission and the proliferation of overpaid bureaucrats loafing and sucking off of our tax dollars while they ignore the homeowners who actually care about the future of East County (west county is gone) and continue to ram though their tacky sterile junk everywhere. the TRAFFIC IS HORRIBLE and worse every week. The quality of life is deteriorating every week thanks to these developers who have run WILD for years and controlled their lackeys in the local government - some gone like that WHITMORE and the other prior tools, some here like KRUSE still doing their best to wreck whats left of the quality of life of our homes. Some of us didnt work all of our lives to live in a parking lot full of strip malls like Orlando and Miami but thats what these developers want while they line their pockets. How many MILLIONS DO THEY NEED? HOW MUCH IS ENOUGH BERUFF? JENSEN? NEAL? Its never enough because they will never stop. The voting populace needs to wake up and get behind you and your team Dr. Mccann before they finish us off in the next few years
Homeowners and taxpayers remember - YOU WILL BE LOOKING AT THIS SUBURBAN BLIGHT AND TRAFFIC FOR YEARS TO COME- IS THAT HOW YOU WANT TO LIVE? Thanks for being open and vocal Dr Mccann, I know my friend Carolann Felts would be very proud of you for standing up to these greedy pigs who are wrecking our homes with their unending trashy developments.
This is even more reason to reject Rahn and Ballard. In 2023, when they were not up for election, a packed chamber and some 500 pages of public comment begged them not to gut the wetland buffers. Ballard, Rahn and Bearden's response was to give the public the middle finger. They did the same for policy 2.1.2.8 which allows developers to leapfrog the rural boundary line. They did the same when Commissioner Kruse was pushing for maximum impact fees. Ballard and Rahn (and Bearden) voted to use an old study to keep impact fees at a minimum. The inescapable lesson here is that, if Rahn and Ballard are re-elected,, they will go back to giving the public the middle finger on developer-related issues. Don't let them hide from their record. Vote out Rahn and Ballard on August 18th.
People should read Tales of Old Florida and then they would understand why the Eden of the United States has been destroyed. Too many Eves taking a bite of the apple.
Mr. Green would have some big shoes to fill. Lisa Gonzalez Moore has done a wonderful job keeping constituents updated and fighting for us in the 4th District. I was skeptical of Councilwoman Moore prior to her election because of her close ties to real estate as an attorney. But, her awareness of our community concerns has always been her focus and for that we're all very grateful.
Commissioners,
I am writing to formally voice my profound disgust and sharp condemnation regarding the egregious, multi-year failure of Manatee County leadership and the Property Management Department to properly maintain the downtown Bradenton parking garage.
Precast concrete filigree structures are engineered to easily achieve a lifespan of 50 to 60 years. However, that longevity is entirely dependent on basic, responsible stewardship—specifically, ensuring the structure is properly sealed against water intrusion. The county utterly failed to execute this baseline preventive maintenance. Now, our community is left holding the bag for a crumbling asset while your administration plays semantic games with public safety and actively misleads the taxpayers.
The timeline of documentation compiled by Karins Engineering between December 2021 and January 2026 exposes an astonishing pattern of official negligence and shifting narratives:
December 2021: Inspectors explicitly warned of widespread "delamination" and hollow-sounding concrete across large portions of the total deck area. They advised that major, invasive repairs were required within 18 to 24 months, carrying an estimated cost of $8.9 million.
The Response: Rather than acting decisively, the former administration chose to declare that the county had "a few years before we actually need to take aggressive action." The county then proceeded to order ten additional inspection reports over four years—spending thousands of dollars to repeatedly read the exact same warnings while the structure continued to rot.
Worsening Conditions: By January 2026, the cumulative damage escalated severely. Delamination on Level 5 jumped from 60% to nearly 80%; Level 3 worsened from 40% to 55%; and the roof level reached a staggering, hazardous 95% top-deck damage. Five of the structure’s deck tops have now crossed or met the 50% threshold of severe structural concern.
Obsolete Recommendations: The engineers explicitly stated in late 2025 and early 2026 that their original 18-to-24-month repair window and the $8.9 million cost estimation were completely obsolete due to the county's prolonged inaction and the compounding deterioration.
Yet, despite your own current County Administrator previously admitting in 2023 that the structure had roughly two years remaining unless millions were poured into it, the county's public relations apparatus is now attempting to claim the situation is "relatively stable." Pretending that a clock resets every time a new inspection report is printed is a direct insult to the intelligence of Manatee County residents.
Most offensive to the taxpayers of this county is the absolute lack of fiscal discipline. In May 2025, this Board voted to approve a budget amendment that stripped the entire $34.8 million originally allocated for the downtown garage rebuild and transferred it to buy and renovate a secondary "East Campus" administration building in Lakewood Ranch.
You completely defunded a critical downtown infrastructure asset before you even opened the Invitation to Negotiate (ITN) for its redevelopment in August 2025. Unsurprisingly, because you completely crippled the project's funding and offered no strategic plan, the ITN failed to produce a viable proposal. Meanwhile, you have readily committed taxpayers to a 20-year generator agreement for the Lakewood Ranch building that will bleed over $12 million alone, while the downtown core is left with an unfunded, disintegrating parking garage.
If Manatee County cannot handle the fundamental responsibilities of public asset management, it has no business managing them.
I demand that the county immediately stop wasting time chasing "second opinions" to downplay structural degradation. The county must move to offload this parking garage to the private sector. Let a private entity take over the parcel, execute the necessary demolition, replace the structure, and maintain it under strict contract.
The public deserves an immediate, transparent accounting of how downtown parking infrastructure will be salvaged after years of deliberate, documented neglect. We need a drastic change in how our community's assets are managed, and we expect accountability now.
Glen GADFLY Gibellina
Candidate for Manatee County Commissioner District 4
https://electglengibellina.com/
That's really sad. 3 Keys had great food and atmosphere and was pet friendly. Motorworks, with seating under the huge tree was kind of magical. And they both had great beer.
Let’s think about this. Is E. Jean Carroll a threat to this democracy? Is she plotting a takeover if the government? Has she done anything that might warrant her being investigated?
Apparently our President thinks so otherwise he wouldn’t use the US Justice Department to investigate her. He owes her 80+ million dollars but the billionaire won’t pay her. Not only is our President a serial *** addict but he is also a cheapskate. If he does pay her he’ll probably obtain the funds from the “criminal slush fund” he developed. Who weaponized who here? James Tierney
There is no such thing as a free lunch in politics. Either the effected programs will be drastically cut causing significant harm to healthcare, education, etc. or citizens will be taxed covertly through sales tax, or other forms of hidden taxation. This is just a major flimflam the Governor is trying to play on us.
Recent Comments
conrope writes:
The property tax blast radius nobody is talking about
lib224@gmail.com writes:
Florida to drop three-day waiting period for firearms
David Daniels writes:
How not to rebuild trust with a community
Dianna writes:
Manatee County Commission Notes: 6/2/26
Manatee Watch writes:
Manatee County is at a Tipping Point
David Daniels writes:
Facing Public Backlash, BOCC Delays Comp Plan Transmittal
kmskepton@yahoo.com writes:
DeSantis tax plan could cost Suncoast counties $380 million in 2 years
kmskepton@yahoo.com writes:
Florida Legislature passes bill to put the elimination of property taxes on 2026 ballot
serenowens@aol.com writes:
EarthTalk: Australia’s Koalas May Have Less Than 30 Years Left
graumli22 writes:
Keith Green enters Ward 4 Bradenton City Council Race
lib224@gmail.com writes:
Suncoast nonprofits strained as political polarization impacts federal funding
lib224@gmail.com writes:
The Governor's New Grift
GLEN GADFLY GIBELLINA writes:
Years after engineers warned of deterioration, county still reassessing future of downtown garage
UteKegel writes:
3 Keys to close, while Motorworks faces foreclosure
jimandlope@aol.com writes:
Justice Department looks at Trump rape accuser; Pope warns us about AI; Could Florida disbar Pam Bondi?
rayfusco68@gmail.com writes:
New growth has not funded adequate infrastructure
rayfusco68@gmail.com writes:
Schools, healthcare, public safety could be hit under property tax plan released by DeSantis
RRICH69176@aol.com writes:
Florida House budget includes $6 million for company of budget negotiator’s husband
Cat L writes:
Leaders of New College of Florida and USF welcome Sarasota land transfer
Cat L writes:
Developers push massive data center complex in DeSoto County amid backlash