BRADENTON — In a March 10 special election, voters in the West Manatee Fire & Rescue District once again rejected giving the district authority to levy a property tax. A referendum that would have allowed the district to impose up to 1 mill in property taxes failed 56% to 44%.
With 17.5% of eligible voters turning out, 1,864 voted no and 1,461 voted yes. Voters rejected a similar proposal in 2004, when the district asked to levy an ad valorem tax. That failed with some voters expressing concerns about potential tax increases and confusion over how the millage would be applied.
Fire officials argue that relying primarily on flat fire assessments creates long-term funding challenges as costs rise and demand for emergency services grows. Two decades later, similar arguments and voter concerns continue to dominate the discussion.
The referendum would have allowed the district to adopt a property tax in the future, capped at 1 mill. A mill equals $1 per $1,000 of taxable property value. If the district adopted the full rate, a home with a taxable value of $500,000 would pay about $500 per year.
Supporters said the measure would modernize the district’s funding structure and create a more stable revenue source for firefighter staffing, equipment and vehicles, station maintenance, and emergency response capacity.
Opponents largely viewed the proposal as another step toward higher property taxes at a time when homeowners are already facing rising insurance costs and property values.
Barrier island communities that depend more heavily on emergency response during storms and evacuations showed somewhat stronger support for the measure, while mainland neighborhoods in West Bradenton, including areas around Palma Sola and Village Green, demonstrated stronger opposition.
3 comments on this item
Only paid subscribers can comment
Please log in to comment by clicking here.
lib224
A total of 10 vehicles from various agencies showed up in an incident where a 97 year old woman had died peacefully recently in Holmes Beach. Actual fire fighting incidents have become increasing rare as fire prevention codes have increased. Voters are overwhelmed by increasing taxes. What elected official actually oversees the fire department?
Wednesday, March 18 Report this
mcmplm
In my recent letter to the editor about the WMFRD tax proposal, I argued that the tax increase proposal was unfair, because the non ad-valorem assessment had already been raised over 7% for each of the last two years - way above the maximum tax increase allowed by the Homestead limit of 3%. Why don't the ten separate fire departments in Manatee County merge into a single administrative unit in order to achieve cost efficiency? Better yet, become an elected Constitutional Office to take advantage of the enormous financial resources that exist on Manatee County's balance sheet.
Mike Meehan, CFA, MBA
Wednesday, March 18 Report this
Dianna
How many additional resources are being used to support ‘hotel houses’ or short-term rental businesses and their guests? Is this increased demand the reason more funding is needed? If so, this funding should come from the bed tax.
Wednesday, March 18 Report this