Thank you Josh Salmon, for this piece and your career of excellent investigative journalism (Josh was an award winning investigative reporter for the Sarasota Herald Tribune before their local reporting took a dive with the likes of Jesse Mendoza). Re: reliance on CDDs, I find it strange that Commissioner Siddique feins concern that "previous County Commissions did not fund infrastructure...they just deflected to CDDs." Yet isn't Siddique doing exactly that? Siddique was part of the 4-3 majority (with Kruse and, of course, Ballard and Rahn) that approved rezoning a large parcel on Buckeye Rd for 186 housing units plus commercial. Talk about approving without infrastructure...Buckeye Rd is a narrow 2-lane road barely wide enough for two vehicles. No shoulder, no turn lane, and Piney Point's toxic waste a stone throw away. Siddique and Rahn (Ballard was absent) also voted to re-zone a parcel in Tara for development of 70 apartments to be built. Again, talk about no infrastructure, Tara Blvd and SR 70 is the most dangerous intersection in the County per the DOT according to testimony, so why would Tal vote to add 70-some new apartments without having minimal safety infrastructure? Tal also spoke in favor of a Pat Neal requested rezone that would allow for over 400 new single family homes in eastern Manatee. (Neal is potential major campaign donor for Mrs. Siddique's recently announced run for the state legislature) Does anyone who has to get from point A to point B in Manatee County feel we have even the bare minimum concurrent traffic infrastructure? Yet Tal was ready to approve 400 urban sprawl homes before the vote was deferred. So how is Tal any different from the "previous County Commissions" he is quoted as criticizing?
Politics and influences on our well being MIRROR what is happening at the national level....powerful entities with deep pockets are controlling the lives of all Americans...so they can fatten their wallets
Illegal and dishonorable behavior to avoid public transparency and oversight seems to be the hallmark of the Corcoran administration that has turned a once internationally known honors college into a political showcase of authoritarian rule, making it a dumbed-down jockshop resembling a private religious "college" with disdain for academic, intellectual, and social freedoms following the repressive political objectives of the governor. All of this has been allowed by the Florida "legislators" who similarly fear the public. Truly pathetic! Replace all of the politicians who have enabled this.
Point 1: State is going crazy with this burdensome and more restrictive regulations by local government. Based on some of the language of SB 180 they are extending the prohibition until 2027. Bill will allow for Comp plan amendments by a private applicant. The way I read this, it will happen with every hurricane from now on that has a federal declaration.
Point 2. Commissioner Felts had already spoken during deliberation for almost 15 minutes after the presentations. If she had just allowed for the vote without speaking again, there probably been a denial. I admire her passion but she needs to learn when to speak and when it is not necessary.
The Trump administration doesn’t seem to know that it’s government of, by and for the people. They are dismantling the parts of the government that serve the citizens. Please pay attention people. Read the constitution. This is OUR government.
Looks like the Supreme Court is ruling for the wealthy developers and not the people of the United States that pay their salaries or the Constitution. We, The United States of American are heading down the path of dictatorship with the help of the nor so supreme, Supreme Court. They need to read the Constitution before every decision they make.
Maybe the county attorney should have a meeting with Commissioner Felts on procedure. She had already deliberated for almost 15 minutes on this project. When it came up for the vote on denial, she got on board to deliberate again which lead to Commissioner Ballard dropping off which know ahead of time she would at 6:30 and because the applicant wanted the full board to vote for denial, it failed. A continuance was granted so now we have to go through this ll over again. Felts added nothing new and got belligerent when Kruse tried to stop her from repeating herself. I admire her passion but she needs to know when to deliberate and when not to. She gave new life to the Neal project that was almost denied before she started her second rant.
Your piece was held out to address environmental concerns and quickly devolved into another bash Israel piece and furthering antisemitism. Jews have been exiled from various homelands for 5000 years and when they finally have one country that they can have self-determination and that is one country too many. In 5000 years there has not been a single century where there has not been genocide of Jews for the "crime" of being Jewish. It is unfathomable that you support a government, Hamas, that wants to oppress it's people as the Taliban does in Afghanistan. Hamas openly states they would commit acctual genocide and thankfully they do not have the wherewithall to do it. In fact with all of the purported genocide in Gaza, since 10/7/23 the population has grown. Another fact you ignore. All of the outrage is directed at ending Israel with no talk of the future oppression that the Palistinians will endure under Hamas. Hamas kills LGBTQ and supports honor killings. That oppression has never been widely reported and never will be. Do not pretend for a second that you care about the people of Gaza.
First and foremost, Manatee County would not be in this position except for the fact that Jason Bearden, Mike Rahn and Amanda Ballard basically gave the middle finger to their constituents in voting for the “county initiated” policy to remove the buffers in Oct. 2023. That decision has already resulted in the loss of pristine wetlands in SW Manatee County along Sarasota Bay in Carlos Beruff’s 529 acre Aqua development. Now, that decision has allowed developers to block reversing the policy. And most costly, if the BoCC follows up their words today with actions, that 2023 “county initiated” policy will cost taxpayers $10’s of thousands, perhaps $100’s of thousands in legal fees.
What does the term “county initiated” mean? It means that the County Administration requested the policy change and argued that wetland buffers were unnecessary, unimportant. The Administration hired Carlos Beruff’s consultant to present their “facts.” They lied through their teeth. We, the taxpayers, pay the Administrator well over $200K, plus a deferred salary, COLA increases, retirement benefits, paid sick and vacation time, top notch health insurance, expense accounts, a new vehicle, travel and hotel etc… In return, the Administrator and all of his top management are supposed to work for us.
But the Administration was working for developers, secretly. This is the definition of corruption. The Administration was actively working against the public. This cannot continue to be swept under the rug. There must be accountability. There must be consequences for what this has already cost us and will soon cost us. Commissioners, stop burying your heads in the sand. This Administration’s fraud and deceit has done great damage to this entire county. We deserve the truth of what happened. Taxpayers deserve an investigation.
Also, isn’t it ironic that what Commissioner McCann was proposing in taking legal action against the Board’s process in removing wetland buffers is the same legal strategy that Joe McClash was pursuing - namely that the BoCC didn’t follow the legal process by stating a public benefit to removing the buffers. So instead of hiring 7 outside attorneys to go after Joe for $250K, the BoCC is now considering filing the same lawsuit to void the 2023 vote by Bearden, Rahn and Ballard. I think that may be the best move. Maybe we could hire Joe to advise our county attorney. He’s probably already done the research.
We need to remember that our local Tallahassee "representatives" Robinson, Boyd, and Conerly voted to remove any chance that a ballot initiative will succeed. What are they afraid of? Meanwhile, they we have been promised that something will be done to address skyrocketing insurance rates - but nothing was done. There was an amendment to a bill that would have reinstated that insurance companies pay attorney fees if they are found to illegally deny a homeowner's claim,(which is how it used to be until 2022, when DeSantis and the legislature gave immunity to insurance companies) but that was voted down because insurance companies have so much power over the people that are supposed to represent us. I am just so fed up with politicians. From the City of Bradenton, Manatee County, and the State of Florida. Carol Felts is the only one that actually cares to represent what is best for the public. There used to be many that I looked up to.
Excellent conversation! Those were our thoughts exactly. We expected to have this conversation at yesterday’s meeting but unfortunately that did not happen.
Everyone on this commission needs to be replaced. Never trust a rushed deal,someone is getting a sweet payoff thanks to the taxpayers. This is just another reason it cost so much to live in this area and why our taxes keep going up. Why put this in the far end of the county?
Once again, much appreciation for an excellent article on the real history of Florida, and the unique and innovative people who envisioned and executed that vision that complimented the unique environment in a sustainable manner, versus destroying it or conforming it to standards that cannot be supported in the future.
Why exactly would citizens want a new administration building that is not centrally located, smaller in size, and near the worst part of I-75 and UTC traffic? How does this benefit citizens? If you add the line items on the agenda it will cost almost 50 million dollars. Common sense says you don’t buy a smaller building when the county and staff are growing at such an alarming pace. Clearly there are plans in place for our current building. It feels like there are still secret and corrupt forces working in the background and not for the good of the citizens. Citizens speak out and submit your comments.
Recent Comments
David Daniels writes:
Florida officials warn: Buyer beware as developer districts spread across the Suncoast
RRICH69176@aol.com writes:
Republicans in Tallahassee Just Won't Stop Attacking Home Rule
Charles writes:
New College Settles Public Records Lawsuit
kmskepton@yahoo.com writes:
Dozens of members of Congress from both parties plead with Trump to unfreeze FEMA grants
sandy writes:
Episode 188: Mitch Maley & Dawn Kitterman
N_Alice_Newlon writes:
Amendment to Emergency Management Bill Seeks to Eliminate More Home Rule on Development
kat.houston writes:
NOAA Announces its Billion-Dollar Disasters Database 'Retired'
lib224@gmail.com writes:
State officials discuss how FHP officers are now making immigration arrests
serenowens@aol.com writes:
EPA Moves Forward in Gutting Federal Wetland Protections
lib224@gmail.com writes:
NOAA puts coastal communities at risk
lib224@gmail.com writes:
Commissioners Double-down on Policy Commitments Despite Possible Legal Challenges
sandy writes:
Felts Fumbles at the Goal Line
neal2k@yahoo.com writes:
EarthTalk: The Environmental Toll of the Israel-Hamas War
David Daniels writes:
Manatee County Gets Sucker Punched on Wetland Policy Reversal
David Daniels writes:
Group hoping to expand Medicaid sues Florida over new constitutional amendment restrictions
Dianna writes:
Episode 187: Mitch Maley & Dawn Kitterman
Bill writes:
BOCC Approves Purchase of Lakewood Ranch Office Complex
Carolannfelts writes:
Bertha Palmer: Sarasota's Glamorous Cattle Queen
Dianna writes:
Manatee County Purchase of LWR Complex for Admin Building Smells Fishy
Dianna writes:
BOCC to Vote on Purchase of New County Administration Building