Events Calendar

Current Weather

Manatee Road Watch

Eat Here - Gulf Coast Cookery Sean Tampa Bay yacht Management Bills Discount Center - New & used Furnature, Appliances and More!

The Bradenton Times Polls

Poll Question: Do you think the labrador mix Padi, who bit and injured a child while the dog was allegedly protecting himself, should be euthanized?

 Yes  No More polls »

The Robyn Report with Robyn Davis Right column ad

Change Text Size: Larger  Smaller

News Section: Commentary

Beach Nourishment or Fueling Looming Disaster?

Published Wednesday, July 16, 2014 12:05 am

They call it "beach nourishment" – but the term is deceiving. What these periodical hundred million dollar projects are doing to Florida's central west coast is undermining a very thin shield of sand that has always protected its barrier islands. If we continue to assault these beaches, nature may eat those islands sooner than we think. 


There are 80 miles of west Florida coastline that run from Anclote Key, just north of Pinellas, to Venice Inlet in southern Sarasota County. The 18 barrier islands that protect this short strip of coastline have always moved around adjusting to nature's way.


But the shoreline of both the islands and the inland no longer resemble nature's way of shifting sands and its redistribution of sediment, which is needed to protect shores from high sea levels; nor do they have the dunes that once protected the coast from large storms.


So when a storm takes a big bite out of a beach redesigned for recreation, the replacement of that bite only enhances the possibility of further radical shoreline erosion.  


Sand pumped from a mile offshore is how all three counties within the 80 mile span retrieve the needed sand to widen their beaches.


But the barrier island chain is centered on a broad sloping carbonate platform, underlined with limestone and bedrock, and its protective sands are of limited thickness. 


This island and inlet system is among the most varied in the world with its combination of low wave energy and micro-tidal conditions that produce a wide range of barrier and inlet morphologies.


In 1992, Congress directed the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) to initiate a 5-year study of this region in order to better understand this barrier island system. This was done in response to a same year report from the Florida Department of Natural Resources that designated 65 percent of west Florida beaches as "critical erosion areas."


Analysis of core samples and seismic data indicate that, in some areas along the coast, the underlying limestone bedrock exerts significant control over the location of the barrier islands.


These islands and inlets show active geological history that dates back 4,600 years to the south, and as early as decades ago to the north; with no evidence of island migration shifting landward over the thousands of years.


Manmade maneuvering of shoreline design is flirting with disaster, should a large hurricane spend any time atop this region. What sand has been removed from one place, and placed elsewhere could magnify inland damage beyond any current estimations.


The redistribution of sand to gain beach acreage and protect structures built in proximity to coastal waters, will only exacerbate the degree of damage should a powerful hurricane strike.


Underestimating the effects from removing millions of tons of sand, from what is a limited source, with lives and property at stake, is reckless and irresponsible; yet all three local governments continue to approve development in high-hazard coastal areas.  


If we continue to ignore the lessons nature has clearly displayed for wider beaches and tourist dollars, our actions could invite a catastrophe to the sun coast.


It was the dredging for Mississippi River Gulf Outlet (MRGO) that allowed the high gulf tides from hurricane Katrina to come inland, flooding New Orleans with water 12 feet above flood lines. Much of west-central Florida is only a few feet above New Orleans.


It is not a matter of if, but when. If our local leaders don't have the knowledge or the will to protect the property and people, they need to get out of the way. 

Join the conversation post Facebook comments here or on our site at the bottom of article.


  In Addition to Facebook Comments You Can Also Post Comments Below

Non-Facebook Comments:

In the 50's I grew up north of Englewood. All those years, I remember the beaches on Manasota Key (a barrier island) would become narrow at times and then very broad --a cycle that kept repeating itself. Anyone who built too close to the beach would have problems. Let's eliminate building too close to the beach and leave mother nature alone. Yes, beach re-nourishment is temporary but (probably)more permanent in bank accounts.
The "insurance pool" suggested by Richard Thomas has merits.
Posted by suzanna young on July 17, 2014

Moving sand around is a zero sum game, i.e. there is no net benefit other than moving public money into private consulting engineers' and dredgers' bank accounts. A much better approach would be to set up an insurance pool paid into by all owners of real property lying seaward of the Florida coastal construction control line. This would be insurance on the land, not the improvements. When the owners decide to abandon their property due to shoreline movement, they may submit a claim which will be covered by the fund in return for quitclaiming all right and title to their land over to the people of Florida. The fund would cover costs of demolition and restoration to predevelopment conditions. You want to own the beach? You pay for that temporary privilege. And when nature sells you short, you leave. Simple.
Posted by Richard C. Thomas on July 17, 2014

Allowing dense and inappropriate development on these shifting islands was the initial action leading to disaster. Trying to protect it from Nature is a folly. Better to spend the money on educating our children.
Posted by Charles Ivarch on July 17, 2014

Bravo, John..Finally this beach re-nourishment sacred cow is being gorged by the truth.
What are poor real estate developers going to do w/o this corporate welfare? Keep up the good work, John
Posted by joe kane on July 16, 2014

Click here to add a Non-Facebook comment to this page

 Sign up for our free news subscription - a great way to stay informed!

News World Round UpSports Roundup

Manatee Rural Health Certificate


Name Date
Richard Shore, III July 29, 2015
Lisa Casper July 30, 2015
Nancy Rowe July 25, 2015
Irene Brothers July 24, 2015
Allene O'Brien June 23, 2015
Dorothy Hill July 28 2015
David Maberry July 24, 2015
Juanita Floyd June 26, 2015
Elizabeth Bennett July 22, 2015
All Obituaries

Copyright © 2009 - 2015 | The Bradenton Times | More than just an Online Newspaper |
405 26 Avenue Bradenton, FL 34205
Phone: 941-896-7857 - Privacy Policy - RSS Feed
Template provided by Free CSS Templates