News Section: Opinion
Banks Strive to Void Credit Union Exemptions
The friction between credit unions and banks has set-off a firestorm. Banks claim credit unions have gotten too big and no longer only serve the poor. Credit unions say they are non-profit, a partnership with the community, and deserve the tax-exemption status their industry was built on.
It has been almost 80 years since Congress granted credit unions their federal income-tax exemption by enacting the Federal Credit Union Act (FCUA). The government's intent was to stimulate post-depression investment by offering credit to those with little means.
In a letter to President Barack Obama last June, The American Bankers Association (ABA) characterized credit unions as a trillion dollar industry that is not worthy of what is projected to soon become a $2 billion annual subsidy.
In recent years, credit unions have been growing by 2-3 percent, creating a membership that now exceeds 95 million. Big bankers see these members as 95 million wallets, and right now they aren't getting a piece of that action.
It is fair to say, big banks are not fighting for the opportunity to provide free-checking -- and few-to-no fees for other services -- to the 95 million customers they hope to jingle from CU memberships.
Just weeks after the ABA letter to President Obama, Bank of America (BOA) posted a net quarterly income increase of 63 percent, or 32 cents a share; compared to the same period a year prior.
Wells Fargo's most recent third-quarter earnings were reported to be up 99 cents a share; Citigroup's third quarter earnings were $1.00 per share, or 30 percent from the period of the previous year.
This week, The New York Times reported that money market rates are continuing to rise, and Forbes reported those rising interest rates could wreak havoc on banks.
It is difficult to see how banks will convince the public -- and politicians running for a 2014 ticket -- to break free from zero banking fees, when the typical American family's income has fallen every year since 2007.
The rising trend of new customers migrating to CU's from big banks, very much mirrors the loss of household income and the number of those falling in or near the poverty line; so some see the increase in CU members, not as a emerging market of new dollars, but moreover, representing the exodus from big bank service fees.
This week, the NYT reported big banks set aside $91.44 billion for 2013 bonuses; these are the same Wall Street mega-banks that are crying foul, saying the credit unions are in their way.
City, County, State and the federal government, invest hundreds of billions of dollars into tax-exempt partnerships -- using taxpayer funds --with claims of public interest, and many of these investments never get close to obliging their stated goals.
USA Today reported that dozens of multi-billion dollar for-profit companies (Verizon, MetLife, Eaton…) pay zero percent (0%) for their effective tax rate.
Citizens for Tax Justice reported that many companies avoid income tax by locating accounts overseas; Nike, Microsoft and Apple are three of them. Last month a Senate hearing revealed Apple only paid two percent on $74 Billion in profits.
The widening gap in economic inequality continues to increase -- separating the rich from the poor -- with numbers not seen since the "Great Depression." Taking away the CU tax exemption will certainly escalate that inequality.
The battle big banks have forged against the CUs, if won, is sure to increase the cost of banking for low income Americans.
These are the same banks that have foreclosed on more than 10 million homes across the country in the past four years; the same banks that were found guilty for foreclosure abuse and fraud; then slapped with $25 billion in fines (a fraction of their profits).
When is enough enough?
My last year with BOA, I must have spent over $400 in fees. In my recent years with a CU, checking and saving fees equate to zero, zilch, nada, nothing. The big banks are clearly making their bucks, with or without my measly accounts. Unless they win this front in the war on the poor, my money's staying in a credit union.
Join the conversation post Facebook comments here or on our site at the bottom of article.
In Addition to Facebook Comments You Can Also Post Comments Below
Click here to add a Non-Facebook comment to this page
Sign up for a free email subscription and get The Bradenton Times' Thursday Weekly Recap and Sunday Edition delivered to your email box each week at no cost.
Sign up for our free news subscription - a great way to stay informed!