Events Calendar

Current Weather

Manatee Road Watch

Eat Here - Gulf Coast Cookery Sean Tampa Bay yacht Management Bills Discount Center - New & used Furnature, Appliances and More!

The Bradenton Times Polls

Poll Question: Do you agree with the school board's plan to introduce a 2016 referendum to add 2 more board members while making elections for the current 5 seats district-wide and the 2 extra seats countywide?

 Yes  No, current representation should not change  No, board should add 2 more members but no countywide elections  No, board should make all elections district-wide only but no new seats More polls »

The Robyn Report with Robyn Davis

Change Text Size: Larger  Smaller

News Section: Local Government

Big and Bold Comp Plan Change Recommended for Coastal Manatee

Published Friday, May 24, 2013 12:05 am

BRADENTON -- The Manatee County Planning Commission took steps to change the county's much-praised Comprehensive Plan for coastal properties at Thursday's meeting. If you own 200 acres or more, want to develop it and can meet all of the other regulatory qualifications, you might be joyed. However, if you are of the environmental persuasion, you may be less thrilled.


The current county Comprehensive Plan has stood firmly and dates back to 1989, with only minor circumstantial amending. What was proposed at Thursday's Planning Commission was a "text" change in the plan. 


The planning staff recommended the Comp Plan not experience the proposed changes, citing legal and environmental concerns. 


The proposed policy changes are with chapter 3 ( and chapter 4 (, of the Comp Plan, and specifies coastal line adjacent to navigable waters. Another specification is the property must be of 200-acres or more and be located along a arterial road.


Staff wasn't alone in its objection to the changes, as a hand full of citizens came to voice their opposition as well. 


Mary Shepard said that building on the shore, where it's vulnerable to hurricanes and large storms, is crazy, adding, "sooner or later nature will have its way." Sandy Ripberger from Sierra Club Manatee said, "It goes against code."


Katie Pierola, ex-Mayor of Bradenton Beach, said the area couldn't stand all of the development, and that the work would surely interrupt efforts to get needed beach projects completed, like the bridge. 


Barbara Angelucci said, "It would be egregious if this proposal was approved," adding, "Neal (Homes) will be in the wings to bring back the Robinson project, and then who knows what else."


Despite all of the criticism to any changes to the county's comp plan, many of the Planning Commission members insisted on finding some way to recommend the project.


Only one member brought up concerns mentioned by citizens, and that was George Mendez. Mendez said he trusted staff knew what they were doing, recognized the sensitive nature of sea grass replacement, as well as many of the other unresolved issues brought up at the meeting.


The other commissioners used one ploy to convince each other to go against conventional wisdom, and that was a catch phrase spoke by the Urban Land Institute Chair, Michael Maxwell, and he said, "Think big and bold."


That was all that those who seemed to be determined to accommodate the applicant needed to hear, and many members repeated it, as if it were a sign that hung over their office door.


One interesting comment came from Tanya Lukowiak, the latest member to be appointed to the planning commission. That was, "I am not sure that anyone who owns hundreds of acres of coastline, shouldn't be made to do something big and bold with it."


Attorney, Ed Vogler, for the applicant, Carlos Beruff, said, "The press should pick up on that comment made by Lukowiak."


Well they did, but it's not clear if all that heard it, took away the same sentiment as did Lukowiak, Beruff and Vogler. 


Vote to recommend approval to the BOCC was, 6 to 1, Mendez dissenting. It will now come before the BOCC at a future meeting for a final vote.

Join the conversation post Facebook comments here or on our site at the bottom of article.


  In Addition to Facebook Comments You Can Also Post Comments Below

Non-Facebook Comments:

It was a sad day for the citizens of Manatee County when the Planning Commission (with the exception of Mr. Mendez) voted to violate their oath to protect citizens by voting to approve the county-wide developer-initiated Text Amendments to our Comprehensive Plan. As Planning Division Manager, Doug Means, stated?."It's the backbone of our environmental protection policies in Manatee County."

As Staff pointed out, the results of this new language from the Text Amendments, as written, would have the effect of allowing exceptions to air quality protection and monitoring, water quality protection and monitoring, protection of wetlands, protection of seagrasses, and protection of residents from the physical and economic effects of natural disasters, including pre-and post-disaster protections, just to name a few.

This was a very bad decision by the Planning Commission (6-1). The developer wants to build something different and ?outside the comfort level?. His attorney stated that the project could be built without the Text Amendments, but not ?the way we want it?. Well as we all know one can?t always get what one wants.

Who is this Tanya Lukowiak anyway? Is this the same person who ran the CRA in Palmetto? If so, didn't they have to pay her $150,000 just to go away?
Now that's BIG and BOLD.
Posted by Barbara Angelucci on May 24, 2013

I hope the B-Times will do an article on where such property exists and who owns it.
Posted by Kathy Morrison on May 24, 2013

Click here to add a Non-Facebook comment to this page

 Sign up for our free news subscription - a great way to stay informed!

News World Round UpSports Roundup

Manatee Rural Health Certificate


Name Date
Thomas Presha June 28, 2015
Ralph Senzamici June 26, 2015
Diane Exten June 27, 2015
Jesse Rumberger June 25, 2015
Larry Hurst June 23, 2015
Robert Johnson June 22, 2015
Ralph Wagner June 22, 2015
Arthur Tennant June 20, 2015
Joseph Perry June 18, 2015
All Obituaries

Copyright © 2009 - 2015 | The Bradenton Times | More than just an Online Newspaper |
405 26 Avenue Bradenton, FL 34205
Phone: 941-896-7857 - Privacy Policy - RSS Feed
Template provided by Free CSS Templates