Events Calendar

Current Weather

Manatee Road Watch


Personal Assistant Bills Discount Center - New & used Furnature, Appliances and More!

The Bradenton Times Polls

Poll Question: What are your feelings regarding climate change:

 We need to take much greater steps to address it  The steps already taken have been adequate  It's an important issue but not enough can be done to be worth the costs  It's a hoax that we need not be concerned about More polls »

The Robyn Report with Robyn Davis Sean Tampa Bay yacht Management

Change Text Size: Larger  Smaller

News Section: National Government



Reform Group Calls on Florida to Join Presidential Popular Vote Initiative

Published Tuesday, July 26, 2011 2:30 am
BRADENTON – The electoral college is constitutionally designated as the system used to elect the President of the United States. But the constitution also leaves the manner in which states apportion their electoral vote completely up to them to devise. A movement is under way to make the popular vote more influential and election reform groups are calling on Florida to join.

National Popular Vote is a non-partisan group that has helped to promote interstate compacts that pledge to award all electoral votes to the winner of the popular vote at the national level. So far, seven states and the District of Columbia have joined, and legislation has been introduced in the other 43 states. The Florida Initiative for Electoral Reform is urging our state to follow suit and Florida Senator Tony Hill (D-Jacksonville) has already introduced a bill to make it so.

“It’s really pretty simple,” says Yury Konnikov, President of FLIER. “Under the National Popular Vote compact, Florida would join other states and the District of Columbia, in agreeing to award all of its electoral votes to the presidential candidate who receives the most popular votes nationally. This ensures that all votes are equal and that all votes matter.”

Of course Florida has a special relationship with the electoral college thanks to our dubious role in the 2000 election, the last time an American President was seated without winning the popular vote. Even though George W. Bush benefited from the electoral college when being appointed President by the Supreme Court after losing the popular vote in 2000, he nearly lost his 2004 bid for reelection, despite winning the popular vote by around 3,000,000 votes that time. If as little as 60,000 of those votes would have shifted just in Ohio, he would have lost the election.

A quiet, but intense war has been underway over the last decade to decide how direct our democracy should be. Opponent groups like the American Legislative Exchange Council have been working hard to defeat referendum style voting, while striving for increased corporate influence by way of removing  campaign contribution limits and creating obstacles that make it harder for people to vote at the polls. Such campaigning has clearly been successful, as 33 states have introduced new voter ID laws this year alone, despite no evidence that voter fraud has been a factor in election results.

In today's presidential races, most states aren't really contested because their electoral college outcome is almost a forgone conclusion. Therefore, a Republican has almost no chance of impacting a presidential election by casting their vote in D.C. or Massachusetts; same for a Democrat in Utah or Wyoming. Such states are going to go the other way, as are all of the electoral votes in the winner-take-all system. If the popular vote counted, votes in such states would be much more meaningful in terms of potential impact on the result.

It's no secret that certain demographics tend to vote in certain patterns. By manipulating the way votes are included and counted, control of the outcomes can be more easily influenced. So while the seemingly simple argument that whomever receives the most votes from American voters in a presidential election should become our president might seem elementary, there is too much at stake to expect such revolutionary changes to come easily.

Though Florida is often considered a swing state, it has voted more reliably Republican at all levels in recent years. With a sweeping GOP majority at the state level, shifting to such a policy will surely be an uphill fight that will require tremendous popular support to achieve.  

Join the conversation post Facebook comments here or on our site at the bottom of article.

 

  In Addition to Facebook Comments You Can Also Post Comments Below



Non-Facebook Comments:


The Founding Fathers also DID NOT create a cult of personality of themselves by which their actions were supposed to be unquestionable. In fact, they put in a process by which their works could be improved on by the people and the people have done just that, amending the Constitution no less than 27 times. It is also a mistake to think that we live in the same system as the Founding Fathers did because if we did most of us would not be allowed to vote for failure to meet property, gender, and continental ancestry requirements. Even the way the modern Electoral College functions is not even remotely the same way it functioned when the Founding Fathers were alive, which is how the first contradictory election of 1824 happened. In the end, the National Popular Vote plan makes sense because it is a way to count all votes without amending the Constitution to eliminate the Electoral College.
Posted by Fran Johnson on July 28, 2011
 

Our founding fathers in their infinite wisdom created the basis on which the election system works. Among other things they rightfully chose to creat and maintain a republic. This effort to emasculate the Electorial College is a backdoor approach to evicerating our Constition and our Bill of Rights. If the progression continues, sooner or later we will not be able to distinguish our Exceptional Nation from other second rate countries. Leave things alone.
Posted by Dick Olson on July 28, 2011
 

Click here to add a Non-Facebook comment to this page




 Sign up for our free news subscription - a great way to stay informed!



News World Round UpSports Roundup

Manatee Rural Health Certificate
 

MidTown Manatee - Shop here - Work here - Play Here - Live Here - Worship Here - Dine Here

Obituaries

Name Date
Joan Eason September 29, 2014
Gene Hunt September 28, 2014
Muriel Thayer September 26, 2014
Patricia Ritchlin September 25, 2014
Glennava Inman September 25, 2014
Jo-Ann Cherry September 22, 2014
Emma Engelmann September 20, 2014
Bonny Cloud September 18, 2014
Marion Forbes September 15, 2014
All Obituaries






Copyright © 2009 - 2014 | The Bradenton Times | More than just an Online Newspaper | http://www.thebradentontimes.com/
405 26 Avenue Bradenton, FL 34205
Phone: 941-896-7857 - Privacy Policy - RSS Feed
Template provided by Free CSS Templates